Lilly has a breakdown when Scott and Molly move in together.
Lilly and her friends looked at Scott and Molly wondering why they had asked them to gather in the living room for an “important” conversation.
Scott began, “Girls, as you know Molly and I have been dating quite a bit these past few months and we have decided to move in together.”
They started yelling and jumping for joy. They spoke over each other, “Holy shit,” “That’s great, “Wonderful,” plus a few words of modern slang that Scott didn’t understand buy assumed they meant the girls all approved.
Then Heidi asked, “What about me and Heather?”
“What about you,” Molly said.
“We do we live?”
“You don’t think your mother would abandon you, do you?,” Scott said, “you will live here with us.”
Heather squealed and threw her arms around Lilly, “We’ll be sisters.” All the other girls gathered around them in a group hug. Everyone was excited. “I’m so happy for you,” said Jenny and the other girls echoed her sentiment.
“I’ve always wanted a sister,” Lilly said.
“Me too,” Heidi said.
“HEY!” Heather said with shock in her voice.
The entire room broke down in laughter as Heidi’s cheeks turned red and she sputtered, “I mean, another sister.”
After the laughter died down, Maria asked, “Are you going to get married?”
Molly replied, “Well, you never know what the future might hold.” She thought to herself, “All he ask to do is ask.”
Amy then looked at Scott and with mock sternness said, “I do hope you have honorable intentions.”
Scott replied, “You never know what the future might hold.”
Amy then looked at Molly and said, “You do realize that a man won’t buy the cow if he’s already getting the milk for free.”
Molly looked thoughtful and then teased, “You might be right. Perhaps we should have separate bedrooms.”
Scott looked mildly panicked and said, “I’ll thank you to keep your opinions to yourself, Amy.”
“I just have one more important question,” she replied.
“What’s that?”
“Are you in love?”
For a moment, Molly was scared but then Scott said, “I love her with all my heart. I have never felt this way about anyone before.”
“What about you, Molly,” Maria then asked, “Do you love Scott?
“Of course,” she answered, “I don’t know why it took so long, but it’s like the stars brought us together.”
“I thought it was his dick,” teased Jenny.
“That too,” laughed Molly.
“Actually, that brings me to my next reason for this discussion,” began Scott, “We have had a lot of fun this past year. I care about all of you girls, and wouldn’t trade one second of we have done together. I have zero regrets and hope you don’t either. But, Molly and I have decided that from now on, we are going to be monogamous.”
“What’s that mean,” asked Heidi, “monogmasnus?”
“Monogamous,” corrected Jenny, “it means exclusive. It means he’s not going to fuck us anymore. Only Molly.”
No one could have predicted what happened next as Lilly burst into tears. She ran to her bedroom and slammed the door.
Everyone looked at each other in confusion. Scott finally got up and said, “I better go see what that’s all about.”
He knocked on the door to Lilly’s room, “Lilly, can I come in?”
“No.”
“Are you sure you don’t want to talk about it? It will make you feel better.”
“No, just leave me alone.”
“Ok, I’ll do that for now. When you’re ready to talk, just let me know.”
He returned to the living room and said, “I don’t know what’s going on. She wouldn’t let me in. She doesn’t want to talk about it. Maybe it’s best to just give her some time alone.”
They all sat there quietly talking about more about Molly and her daughters moving in. The house was big enough that Heidi and Heather could each have their own room, though Heather wondered if Lilly would be open to sharing with her.
All of the girls expressed their disappointment that the fuck sessions with Scott were ending, but they were all also grateful for what he had taught them. They are all more assertive about their own sex lives and hard boundaries about what they were willing to do and who they were willing to do it.
After a little while, Jenny said, “Maybe Lilly will talk to me. Sometimes girls tell their friends things they won’t tell their parents.”
She went to Lilly’s bedroom but returned quickly. “No luck. She wouldn’t let me in. I guess she needs more time.”
They all continued talking and after about 15 minutes, Amy decided to talk to Lilly. Like Scott and Jenny, she was rebuffed. Every 15-20 minutes, each girl took a turn at trying to talk to her, but Lilly just wouldn’t open the door.
Finally, Molly said she thought she knew what the problem was and went to talk to Lilly.
She knocked on the door and said, “Lilly. Let’s talk. I think I know what’s bothering you.”
“No, you don’t.”
“I haven’t even said anything yet, but it would be a lot easier if I didn’t have to talk through the door.”
“Please, just go away. You can’t possibly know how I feel.”
“Lilly, dear. It’s ok, I won’t start living with your father until you are fine with it.”
Suddenly, there was the sound of Lilly’s footsteps and then she yanked open the door.
Her eyes were red and puffy and she said through her tears, “Do you think that’s the problem?”
“Well,’ replied Molly, “you never acted like this before we said we were moving in together.” Molly stepped inside the room, took Lilly by the hand and they say down on her bed together.
“I’m sorry,” Lilly said, “I didn’t want to make you feel bad. I love you. I’ve been hoping for this for a long time. I want you to move in. I’ve never had a mom, you know. I tell Dad that it doesn’t bother me, and usually it doesn’t, but…”
“but sometimes there are things that man just can’t understand,” Molly finished.
Lilly nodded and then buried her face in Molly's shoulder and started sobbing again. Molly didn’t say anything, just held her and let her cry.
Finally, Lilly composed herself and said, “But I don’t think a woman would understand this either.”
“Understand what? You need to tell me what’s on your mind before we can really talk about it.”
“I can’t, you’ll think I’m a freak.”
“I won’t think you’re a freak.”
You’ll think I’m sick.”
“I won’t think you’re sick.”
“You’ll think I’m a sick freak.”
“Lilly,” Molly said trying to hide her frustration, “You aren’t making any sense. Nothing you can say would ever make me think you are a sick freak.”
“It’s because Dad isn’t going to fuck anyone but you anymore.”
“I’m sorry, I’m still not understanding.”
“That means he won’t fuck me. I’m a sick freak because I want my father to fuck me.”
Molly eventually came back to the front room and said, “Girls, go to the kitchen make sandwiches for lunch. I need to talk to Scott alone.”
“Should we make one for Lilly?” they asked.
“No, she can have one later, she’s asleep.”
“Asleep?” Scott said.
“You are such a man. It’s exhausting to be a girl, she needs some sleep.”
She turned and said, “Go girls. I’ll let you know when you can come back in.”
After they left, Molly said, “She finally told me what was wrong.”
“I hope it’s not us moving in together.”
“Not really, though that is part of it. It’s us being monogamous that’s the problem.”
“I don’t understand,” Scott said.
“I’ll explain, but first you have to promise that you won’t think your daughter is a sick freak.”
“A sick freak?”
“Her words. Promise?”
“I can’t imagine anything that could possibly make me think that.”
“She wants you to pop her cherry.”
“What?”
“She wants you to be the man that fucks her for the first time.”
“Why?”
“Maybe because you deflowered all her friends.”
“Not Heidi.”
“No, you just taught Heidi how to suck dicks. Which, if she doesn’t get her grades up, might turn out to be her only marketable skill.”
“I didn’t deflower Jenny either.”
“I think you are missing the point.”
“No, I’m not missing it. I’m just trying understand it.”
“Do you know why I love you?”
“Why?”
“Because you are greatest guy I’ve ever met. That’s the same reason all those girls in the kitchen love you. But before any of us loved you, Lilly loved you. She has spent her entire life living with the greatest guy in the world. Then you started sleeping with all her friends and rejected her.”
“I never rejected her,” Scott protested.
“Not in words, no. But in her mind you did. I’ve had your dick in my mouth. So has every girl in that kitchen. You’re first night with Heidi, you came in her mouth. But have you ever even put your tongue in Lilly’s mouth.
Scott shook his head no.
“That same tongue, by the way, that has been in all of our pussies. She’s been a witness to a lot of sexual adventures in this house, but she’s never been a participant. Do you remember when you were all in the hot tub at the cabin and you told her she didn’t need to take her top off?”
“Yes, I didn’t want her to feel weird.”
“She took it to mean that you didn’t want to see her because her breasts were so small.”
“That’s ridiculous. Heidi doesn’t even have breasts yet and I still think she’s hot.”
“Well, the cabin trip was before you got with Heidi. But after you got with Heidi, she started thinking that maybe it wasn’t her tiny breasts that turned you off. Maybe you just didn’t think she was pretty at all.”
“That’s crazy. She’s absolutely gorgeous. You know, I always waited for those girls to approach me, but I don’t know if I would have done that for Lilly if she wasn’t my daughter.”
“What would you have done if she had approached you?”
“I don’t know. She’s my daughter.”
“She’s a woman that wants her first fuck to be from a man that loves and cherishes her.”
“But it’s incest.”
“This isn’t like the royal family in Europe 500 years ago.”
“What does that have to do with anything?”
“They had so much inbreeding, their kids were like alien creatures. But you can’t get her pregnant, remember. It’s not like she’s going to give birth to some mutant baby with six fingers, webbed feet, and a tail. You are just going to introduce her to the world of pleasure. My father was a kind sweet man. I would have been so much happier if he had been my first instead of some unknown stranger violating me when was unconscious. He died when I was nine, so he never got the chance. And no other good man in my life stepped up either. Sex was miserable for me for years until I got lucky enough to meet you. Do you want that for Lilly? What if she never gets that lucky? A girl that doesn’t feel loved by her father will spend her life trying to find a substitute. And there are far too many shitty creeps willing to take advantage of that. Then she ends up feeling even worse than she did before.”
Scott sat silently thinking for a bit, then heard a soft voice, “Daddy?”
It was Lilly. She had entered the room so quietly, they hadn't even noticed until she spoke.
Scott looked at her and said, “Hi sweetie. Are you feeling better?”
“I guess. But I really want to apologize. I shouldn’t have acted the way I did. I'm sorry. I should have just talked to you and explained what was going on.”
“It’s ok. Molly explained everything.”
“You don’t think I’m a sick freak?”
Scott gave her a warm smile and said, “No, I don’t think you’re a sick freak. I think you are the most beautiful girl in the world.”
“What about Molly?”
“I think you are the most beautiful girl in the world not named Molly.”
Lilly returned his smile, then shyly asked, “So what are we going to do?”
“Do you really want me to be your first?”
“Yes.”
“Then I’m honored.”
Lilly smiled big and said, “Ok, let’s do it.” She grabbed his hand and started to pull but then Molly interrupted.
“Hold on,” she said, “If you’re going to do this, you’re going to do it right.”
“What do you mean,” Scott asked.
“Romance, flowers, dinner, silk sheets. The whole works. It’s not just for sad old ladies. You are going to take her on a proper Daddy-Daughter date.”
“You are not a sad old lady,” Scott said.
“Not anymore. But this isn’t about me. It’s about Lilly. She deserves to get, as you like to say, all dolled up”
“I suppose you want to borrow my credit card,” Scott said with a smile.
“Unless you think she doesn’t deserve it.”
"Of course, she deserves it.”
“Leave it all to me,” Molly said.
Lilly clapped her hands, give a fast kiss to her father, than one to Molly and before they could do anything she ran to the kitchen and announced to the other girls, “Dad’s going to pop my cherry.”
They were shocked and there was an awkward silence, and finally Maria asked, “Isn’t that a bit unusual?”
“Well,” said Lilly looking a bit deflated, “all of you have slept with him? Why can’t I?”
Jenny gave her a comforting smile, “I would say that everything we’ve been doing with your father is a bit unusual. But, it’s also been great. I guess we didn’t think about you not being involved. If this is what you want, we are happy for you.”
“Also,” said Amy, “you’re gonna love the way he fucks.”
They all laughed and Maria said, “I’m sorry for what I said. I was just surprised.”
Lilly gave her a hug and then Heather asked, “So are you going to do it in your room or his?”
“I don’t know, we haven’t gotten that far.”
“Maybe he should just bend you over the table right now,” said Amy.
“Are you going to give him a blowjob?” asked Heidi. “If you do, you should let him cum in your mouth. He tastes good, right Heather?”
“Heidi, don’t tease your sister,” Molly said as she and Scott walked into the kitchen. “Lilly can do anything she wants. And just like the rest of us, she doesn’t have to do anything she doesn’t wasn’t to do.”
“So when are you going to do it,” asked Jenny”
“Next weekend,” Scott said, “Molly insists that I take her on a proper date.”
“That means,” added Molly, “no slumber party. I bet your parents might actually like to see you and know you are still around.”
For Lilly, the week both flew by and dragged on forever at the same time. Molly took her out dress shopping and to get her hair done and to get a mani-pedi. They were going to go to Victoria’s Secret, but Lilly got cold feet at the last second and so they just got her a new bra and panties set from the department store. But, Lilly did insist that it be red. She felt that was pretty bold. After discussion, it was decided that the date would be more low-key than the date with Molly had been. Lilly didn’t fee sophisticated enough for fine dining so they went a family restaurant instead. And they decided no hotel. Lilly also wanted to use her bed. All of her friends had been fucked by Scott in his bed, she decided that her first fuck would be the bed’s first fuck too.
Molly banished him from the house the morning of the date. He had to go to her house to get ready while Molly and the girls helped Lilly. They stripped down her bed and put on brand new silk sheets. They had brought brand new pillows and ensured the entire house was clean. Not that it was a big mess, but a little dusting vacuuming and general straightening made it look better. Lilly didn’t understand why they were cleaning rooms she and Scott wouldn’t be using that night, but Molly said that ensuring the entire house was perfect would enhance the experience. Heather and Heidi suspected that her mother was just making up excuses to “mother” Lilly. But since they had been with Scott before she knew about it, she didn’t get the chance to do that with them, so they humored her and tried to make everything perfect.
Finally it was time. Heidi and Heather were watching out the front window as saw Scott drive in an unfamiliar. While Molly was helping Lilly all week with her preparations, he made some of his own and trading in his car for a new one. A dark blue Mercedes-Benz. He came to the front door and knocked. He thought it was silly to knock on his own door, but Molly insisted it would make Lilly feel special.
So he knocked. Heather opened the door and said, “How can I help you?”
Scott replied, “I have come to call on the lovely, lady Lilly. Is she ready?”
“Come inside and I will let her know.”
Scott stepped in and stood in the foyer waiting for Lilly. Again he felt silly, this was his house. He could walk around in dirty underwear if he wanted to. But, he wanted to make Lilly happy, so he wasn’t going to do anything to ruin the moment.
That was when Lilly appeared at the top of the stairs. She was wearing a red satin dress that fell just above her knees. It had it was short sleeves, hugged her figure, and highlighted her small bust pushing her breasts up and forward. Scott thought she looked like an angel.
She walked down slowly, hoping to portray both the elegance and sexiness she saw movies stars portray when they walk a red carpet.
When she got to the bottom, Scott gave her the bouquet of lilies he had brought for her. They weren’t traditional flowers for dates but they were her favorites. One of the few good things her mother had done was to name her after such beautiful flowers.
Heather took them from her and then Lilly reached up and wrapped her arms around Scott’s neck. He leaned down and they had their first real kiss. Not as father and daughter, but as lovers. Lilly was ecstatic. She had butterflies in her stomach and wondered if she would be able to eat.
After the kiss, they bid goodnight to Molly and the girls. Scott wondered just want kind of prank they were planning, but figured it wouldn’t be too bad. They wouldn’t want to ruin the evening. But he knew they would do something.
He put it out of his mind, though and walked Lilly to the car. He opened her door and helped her in, then went around to his side, got in, started it up and headed towards the restaurant.
About halfway there, Lilly screamed, “What happened to our car?”
“Did you just now notice,” Scott said.
“I guess I wasn’t paying much attention back at the house. Where did this come from?”
“From the dealer.”
“Duh, I figured that much. But, this is so fancy. You always said that you didn’t like fancy cars. Just a way to get from one place to another.”
“Lots of changes in our lives happening lately. I decided that I deserved a fancy new car. Do you like it?”
“I love it. These seats are really comfortable.”
“They should be for the price I paid.”
“HA!” Lilly exclaimed, “I knew you didn’t really want a fancy car. You got this for me. You should let me drive.”
“Not on your life. Do you know much it would cost to add you to the insurance?”
“I thought we were rich.”
“We’re better off than most. Don’t ever take that for granted. We could just as easily be poor. But we might as well be bums compared to the people running insurance companies.”
They arrived at the restaurant. They were a bit overdressed, but not totally out of place. A few other people were also wearing a suit or a dress, even though most people were casual.
They sat at a small table and spoke in low whispers. For some reason, Lilly started asking about her mother. Scott answered her questions as gently as possible, but he was still honest. Lilly deserved to know the truth and Prudence didn’t deserve to look better than she really was.
They talked and laughed. Anyone watching them would think it was just a regular father and daughter having a nice evening together. They would never suspect what they planned later that night.
After dinner, Scott drove them to a secluded area just outside of town. It was a nature preserve that was open to the public, but the public never seemed to visit. They were alone for miles. He parked and then revealed another surprise. His new car was a convertible. He put the top down, then turned off the car, killing the headlights. Being far enough away from the city, there no other lights except the stars. Even the moon wasn’t out tonight.
Lilly was mesmerized. She never really paid attention to the stars before. She couldn’t really see them in the city. Now she couldn’t believe just how many there where., Then entire sky was black but with tiny little pinpricks of light.
They got out and took a little walk. Not too far, since it was dark, but there was a pretty clear trail they could follow easily even without much light.
When the retuned to the car, Scott said, “Why don’t we get in the backseat for a little bit.”
Lilly didn’t understand why, but agreed. They got in, Scott put his arm around her, she cuddled up against his side. Then he gently took her chin and turned her face towards his. He leaned down and kissed her. Now Lilly understood. With the center console, they couldn’t make out in the front.
She felt his tongue pushing against her lips and parted them to accept it. She felt aroused and excited his kisses and then even more excited as he started petting her breasts through her dress. It was incredible. This was the attention she had craved from her father. She’d wanted it for months. She needed it.
And now she was finally getting it. It had been hard to wait, but all her desires were now coming true.
Their kisses continued and Scott moved his hand down to her knees. He started sliding it under her dress, along her thigh, as he approached her crotch, she spread her legs and he touched her pussy through the material of her panties. They were moist with her juices and which got him hard, but he wanted to focus on her completely for now.
He moved her panties to the side, exposing her pussy. He ran his finger up along the lips of her pussy until he found her clit. He continued kissing her as he rubbed her pussy. They were strong powerful kisses full of passion and lust. She was happy and the feeling of his fingers moving up and down on her pussy quickly brought her to orgasm.
“Oh Daddy,’ she cried, “that’s so good. I think I’m gonna cum. Yes, yes, I’m cuming Daddy, I’m cumming.”
Her climax vibrated through her entire body. Scott took his hand away and stopped kissing her. She just lay there. Content, peaceful, happy. She closed her eyes. She wanted to stay in this moment forever.
But then she wanted a better moment. She sat up quickly and said, “take me home, Daddy. Take me home and take me to bed.”
Scott didn’t need to be asked twice. They moved back to the front seat, put the top up and drove home. Scott drove as fast as he dared. He didn’t want to get a ticket, but he was desperate to get there quickly. He made a lot of rolling stops when he hit a stop sign. Luckily they never saw a cop and got there in record time.
Scott remember to act like a gentleman and open the door for Lilly. He took her by the arm and escorted her to the front door. He unlocked it, they went inside and discovered the prank by Molly and the girls.
It wasn’t really a prank. They had decorated the foyer with hearts, they had wrapped ribbon around the bannister, and when they got to Lilly’s room, there was a sign on the door that said, “The Love Room – Virgins Wanted.”
They laughed and went into her room to find that they had also replaced the normal light bulbs with soft pink ones that gave off a gentle glow.
Lilly loved it. It was so romantic. Her future mother and sisters were so wonderful. She was almost overcome with a feeling of happiness, then she looked into the face of her handsome father and started feeling overcome with a feeling of lust.
She turned her back to him, lifted her hair and asked, “Would you unzip me?”
Scott did so and Lilly let her dress fall to the floor. She turned back around and faced him wearing only her red bra and panties.
She reached behind her back, unhooked her bra and let that fall to the floor.
She stood before him and then asked, “I hope you don’t think my boobs are too small.”
There were small, only 32A, but Scott didn’t care. “Those are about the most perfect pair of boobs I have ever seen.” He took her hand and pulled her towards him, he turned her as she settled her back against his torso and he reached around to cup a breast in each hand.
He leaned down and kissed her neck while he skillfully groped her boobs. He gave each little tit a pinch, making her nipples hard. He moved them down towards her pussy, but just as he got there he moved them around to her backside and cupped her asscheeks. She was so happy, so excited, so aroused.
She stepped away from him and walked towards the bed. She turned back towards him and asked, “I may be a virgin, but I think I know enough to know that you can’t fuck me unless you take off your pants.”
Scott unbuckled his belt, unbuttoned and unzipped his pants. As they fell to the floor he also removed his shoes. He then dropped his undershorts and stepped out of them. His hard dick poked out from under dress shirt and Lilly said, “I guess you can fuck with a shirt on, but I think you should take it off.”
He did so and stood before her, hard dick now revealed in all its glory. He started to bend down to take off his socks, but Lilly stopped him. “Leave those on,” she said.
“Why?”
Lilly shrugged and said, “I don’t know. I just like the idea.” So Scott left them on.
He stood there admiring his daughter’s body. He couldn’t believe he was about to fuck his own daughter. The thought of that taboo action and seeing her perfect body almost had him cumming while just standing there.
He then said, “I’m not a virgin and I do know enough to know you can’t fuck while wearing panties.”
Lilly laughed a little, then removed them.
She stood there completely naked. Her hairless pussy seemed to reflect the pink light of the room. She was the image of feminine perfection that artists spent their entire lives trying to create.
She lay back on her bed and spread her legs. Scott approached her started to lean his head down so he could eat her out. She stopped him.
“No, Daddy,’’ she said, “Just fuck me.”
“Are you sure?”
“I’m horny, I’m wet, I’m ready, and I want you to pop my cherry.”
Scott knelt between her legs, he took his hard dick and rubbed it up and down along her pussy lips. Then he found the opening to her pussy and began to push his dick inside.
He went slowly and soon was met with resistance. He pushed firmly until her hymen tore.
She winced, but didn’t make any sound.
“Are you ok,” Scott asked?
“Yes, Daddy, fuck me now. Cum inside my pussy. Fill me up.”
Scott thrust in and out, slowly at first then faster. More insistent. He was getting more and more excited with each pump. He looked down at his daughter. This vision of loveliness. He wanted so badly to make her happy but his lust was too much. It overcame him and he just couldn’t think about her anymore.
He fucked her harder and harder until he exploded. His dick shot ropes of cum into her pussy. It was pure ecstasy.
Finally, he collapsed and laid next to her. She rolled over and laid partially on top of him.
“Thank you, Daddy,’ she said, “Can I ask you a question?”
“Anything.”
“Was I any good for a virgin?”
“Sweetie, you were great.”
“Better than my friends?”
“Promise not to tell?”
“I promise.”
“Not only were you better than your friends, you were better than Molly.”
To MJHasley2023. Thank you. I'm glad you like it. When I posted this story, I thought it would be the last one. But, last night I thought of another chapter. So watch for that sometime in the next few days.
rat68Report
MJHasley2023Report